The town of Patagonia was named for the surrounding Patagonia Mountains, themselves named after the Patagonia Mine, purchased from Mexico in 1858. During the early mining years, the people of Patagonia longed for a place of worship.
In 1859, a circuit rider, Reverend Tuthill, began preaching along the banks of Sonoita Creek. Over time, Methodist circuit riders regularly served southern Arizona under the guidance of the Methodist Mission Board in Philadelphia.
After World War I, the foundation of today’s church took shape. In 1920, R.R. Richardson, considered the founder of Patagonia, donated two lots for a church building. Construction took place over several years, with labor and craftsmanship provided by church members, friends, and neighbors.
In the 1950s, local rancher Harold Thurber led efforts to expand the church. Thurber Hall was dedicated in 1959 and continues to serve as an educational and community gathering space.
In 1983, a neighboring home was purchased to house a Thrift Shop and Preschool. A new extension from Thurber Hall was completed in 1991, adding classrooms, restrooms, and expanded Thrift Shop space. The Preschool closed in 1989.
A treasured focal point of the sanctuary is the black oak cross, crafted by Lyle Allen, a former mayor of Patagonia, from wood grown in the nearby Santa Rita Mountains.
The church is often called “The Jewel Box Church” because of its magnificent stained-glass windows. Most were created by congregation member Jean Burger, with installation completed between 1988 and 1992.
In 2010, the wider community came together to install a new roof for the sanctuary. That same spirit of generosity continued in 2020 with the replacement of the roof on Thurber Hall.
Today, Patagonia is a quiet village known for its natural beauty and birdwatching along Sonoita Creek. This country church, with its stained glass, black oak cross, and devoted congregation, continues to serve the community and welcomes all who seek a place of faith, reflection, and belonging.